Click on the link for an introduction to the concept of the BethRant.
President Obama spoke recently in Roanoke, Virginia. I have not seen the transcript of his speech. For purposes of this rant, I will presume Mr. Limbaugh’s quote is accurate. Taking Mr. Limbaugh’s version, the President made the following statement:
The quote that seems to have bothered Mr. Limbaugh so is the line, “you didn’t get there on your own”.
From this simple statement – that even the wealthy did not spring preternaturally from the forehead of some unsuspecting god – Mr. Limbaugh concludes that Mr. Obama:
• hates America
• is a radical
• is trying to “dismantle the American dream”
• is engaging in Marxist classism (whatever that means - didn’t Marx ‘preach’ the elimination of class?)
• is demonstrating contempt for the country (interesting - even if true, Obama’s ‘contempt’ was for the wealthy, which Limbaugh conflates with the country itself - wow - I never knew being rich was being American while being poor was being something else - who’s the classist now, Mr. Limbaugh?)
• is ruthless
• is a despiser of America
• is a despiser of the way America was founded
• is a despiser of the way America became great (I’m guessing Mr. Limbaugh means we became great because the Carnegies, and not the Debs, made us that way)
Are you kidding me?
Apparently not.
At least not according to my own FB page, wherein a series of RNC (Republican National Committee) ads show a series of photos of entrepreneurs with Mr. Obama laughing superimposed on the picture, with the tag line, “You didn’t build that”, RNC FB page, a clear link to Mr. Limbaugh’s screed.
The fact is that Mr. Obama did not say “you didn’t build that”, even according to Rush Limbaugh.
The fact is that Mr. Obama did say, “you didn’t do it alone”.
The fact is that no sane person would argue with that.
Christian sane people presumptively say that all that they do, they do with the aid, assistance, and intervention of the divine, hence do they never act alone.
Religious and non-religious sane people universally thank their moms when they finally make it on television in a sporting event – an obvious observation that they would not even be present on the planet but for the actions of at least two other people – their parents.
Business owners routinely tell their employees, “we couldn’t have done it without you”. I always believed them. Was I being naive?
Here’s the thing: what on earth is so very threatening about the concept of recognizing that we are an interdependent species? What do we lose by acknowledging that we need each other? I really and truly wish I understood that one.
I don’t know if it would make me a better person, but I’m betting if I understood I’d be a way better pastor.
But for the love of whatever you hold dear to, would you – my friends and family and neighbors and fellow citizens – all of you – just stop this nonsense.
Disagree with the guy if you’re of a mind to.
But spare me, you, and the rest of us the ridiculousness of pseudo-analysis that would take one construct and turn it into another. You betray a lack of persuasiveness when you stoop to saying down is up.
RantEnd
***
There are a lot of wealthy, successful Americans who agree with me — because they want to give something back. They know they didn’t — look, if you’ve been successful, you didn’t get there on your own. You didn’t get there on your own. I’m always struck by people who think, well, it must be because I was just so smart. There are a lot of smart people out there. It must be because I worked harder than everybody else. Let me tell you something — there are a whole bunch of hardworking people out there. The Blaze
The quote that seems to have bothered Mr. Limbaugh so is the line, “you didn’t get there on your own”.
From this simple statement – that even the wealthy did not spring preternaturally from the forehead of some unsuspecting god – Mr. Limbaugh concludes that Mr. Obama:
• hates America
• is a radical
• is trying to “dismantle the American dream”
• is engaging in Marxist classism (whatever that means - didn’t Marx ‘preach’ the elimination of class?)
• is demonstrating contempt for the country (interesting - even if true, Obama’s ‘contempt’ was for the wealthy, which Limbaugh conflates with the country itself - wow - I never knew being rich was being American while being poor was being something else - who’s the classist now, Mr. Limbaugh?)
• is ruthless
• is a despiser of America
• is a despiser of the way America was founded
• is a despiser of the way America became great (I’m guessing Mr. Limbaugh means we became great because the Carnegies, and not the Debs, made us that way)
Are you kidding me?
Apparently not.
At least not according to my own FB page, wherein a series of RNC (Republican National Committee) ads show a series of photos of entrepreneurs with Mr. Obama laughing superimposed on the picture, with the tag line, “You didn’t build that”, RNC FB page, a clear link to Mr. Limbaugh’s screed.
The fact is that Mr. Obama did not say “you didn’t build that”, even according to Rush Limbaugh.
The fact is that Mr. Obama did say, “you didn’t do it alone”.
The fact is that no sane person would argue with that.
Christian sane people presumptively say that all that they do, they do with the aid, assistance, and intervention of the divine, hence do they never act alone.
Religious and non-religious sane people universally thank their moms when they finally make it on television in a sporting event – an obvious observation that they would not even be present on the planet but for the actions of at least two other people – their parents.
Business owners routinely tell their employees, “we couldn’t have done it without you”. I always believed them. Was I being naive?
Here’s the thing: what on earth is so very threatening about the concept of recognizing that we are an interdependent species? What do we lose by acknowledging that we need each other? I really and truly wish I understood that one.
I don’t know if it would make me a better person, but I’m betting if I understood I’d be a way better pastor.
But for the love of whatever you hold dear to, would you – my friends and family and neighbors and fellow citizens – all of you – just stop this nonsense.
Disagree with the guy if you’re of a mind to.
But spare me, you, and the rest of us the ridiculousness of pseudo-analysis that would take one construct and turn it into another. You betray a lack of persuasiveness when you stoop to saying down is up.
RantEnd
