Showing posts with label Iraq lessons. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iraq lessons. Show all posts

Monday, July 7, 2014

Iraq and the Lessons of History: If You Want to Go Back in Time, John McCain


Iraq is in deep trouble.  ISIS and crises abound.

But the let’s-go-back-in-time . . . I-was-right-you-were-wrong crowd make me a little crazy here in the United States as they scream their school-yard analyses before any fool who will give them air time.

1. The desire to go back in time is a waste of . . . time John McCain and others who yell loudest about how ‘we’ (translate the United States military) should not have left Iraq are like those who challenge my pacifist leanings by demanding to know whether I would have killed Adolf Hitler if I had the chance.  It seems so obvious to me, but just in case it’s slipped the attention of the would-be time travelers:

a. We cannot go back in time.  And no one – no one – knows what they could have, should have, would have done.  All we know is what we did or did not do.

b. If we’re going to engage in hypothetical time travel, we actually get to pick when to go back to.  So to the Hitler hypotheticalists, I usually reply that if I’m going to time travel with World War II and the Holocaust in view, I’m not traveling to Hitler’s bunker.  I’m traveling instead to the treaties of post-World War I.  Or to Hitler’s infancy and childhood, when his maniacal character was no doubt formed.  If I’m allowed the magic of changing the past, I’m changing the economic wasteland of post-World War I Germany.  Or the colonializing madness of that same time period.  Or the life of a then-anonymous small boy and his family.

c. if we’re going to time-travel Iraq, I’m going first to when George W. Bush is president in the U. S., toying with invading a country under the cover of the events of September 11, 2001.  Or the same U. S.’ earlier support of a tyrant named Saddam.  Or the installation by the West of a non-native king.  Or the creation of something called Iraq in the first place as a fiction suited and well-suited for the purpose of the exploitation of the natural resources of the region.  (World War II is not the only thing Europe has to answer for).

2. I don’t have the answers and neither does John McCain.  I’ve been to Iraq far more frequently and spent far more time with the peoples of that country than John McCain.  No one is beating down my door for answers.  Nor should they.  This is not my country and I do not have the answers for Iraq.  Neither do John McCain nor the others of his ilk.  And call me silly, but I’ve long understood that if someone doesn’t have anything to contribute to the conversation, maybe they should just be quiet.

3. Next time we go nation-building (and sadly, it’s fairly predictable we will), perhaps we should pay more attention to the ‘small’ things – they matter.  Mr. McCain and others allow their focus to be drawn to the obvious: the presence of a military threat in Iraq.  It is real.  And their attention is understandable, if a bit late.  But here’s the thing: the problems that make a collection of folk like ISIS possible are legion.  And none of them were deemed of much importance at the time (recall the aftermath of World War I, where the world began the long reaping of the insanity that is the Middle East today).  They include:

a. cookie-cutter global thinking that led in the first place to the creation of a nation (Iraq) out of a collection of territories or tribal regions.  The United States should be able to understand regional or local loyalties: after all, we fought a civil war over that very thing as north and south lined up and border regions foundered in mixed loyalties.  Robert E. Lee resigned his commission with the United States Army in order to serve with his beloved Virginia.  Whoever said that all politics is local knew whereof he spoke.

b. the rights you give up on behalf of someone else today will bite them and you tomorrow.  During the strange time when the United States determined that Iraq should have a constitution, there were long and strong and important wranglings over its content.  I actually listened to a gentleman on television – retired CIA – state regarding women’s rights that it was no big deal to throw women under the bus in Iraq’s constitution – after all, he said (I paraphrase), Iraq’ll just be where the U. S. was before the constitutional amendment giving women the right to vote in the U. S.  It was said dismissively.  It was said with no thought to the cost to the women who made that reality change.  It was said with no understanding that in his own beloved United States, before the franchise for women, women were much as they are around the world today, unable to own property in their names, presumptively disqualified to have custody of their children in the event of divorce, hampered if allowed at all to engage in commerce, viewed as inherently incapable of making important decisions like who should be their president, and locked in to violent marriages with virtually no recourse societal or legal.  The United States apparently agreed with this man whose name I cannot recall and the women of Iraq were relegated once again to virtually no voice as Sharia law was constitutionally enshrined in Iraq.

c. Every parent learns, to their chagrin, when they teach their children resistance in any form, sooner or later, will be used against them.  So it is everywhere; so it has been in Iraq.  Thus Maliki’s position as leader of this would-be nation leads inevitably to the events of today as he fails to grasp the lessons of his own recent history.  Put another way, we cannot be surprised when the oppressed become the oppressor.  It happens time and again.  Mr. Maliki had (many legitimate) axes to grind.  But in the grinding, he becomes the thing he so hated.  And the cycle continues.  The United States did the same thing: hating being attacked on our own shores, we attacked others on theirs and claim surprise at the lack of gratitude over the legacy of the dead.

d. Self-interested exploitation rather than genuine economic development yields predictable results.  Iraq is land rich in resources, yet many of its people live in gross poverty.  There is literally no reason save the greed of the powerful for this.

I could go on: wilful cultural ignorance; the unwillingness to listen to anyone with a contrary voice; mass detentions of young men for the crime of being young men; surrendering our own values to the crucible of war; teaching the ways of war rather than teaching the ways of peace; the naivete of the many soccer-balls from home mini-projects; the failure to even consider the inevitable chaos that occurs when war comes to town; failure to understand or address currency, commerce, and economics in a very different culture; ignoring the imams; raining money on the wrong people in the wrong places at the wrong times in order to buy a little space for our soldiers; failing to address every-day policing in a sane way; treating civilians like problems rather than solutions; using military rather than police philosophies with the civilian population (killing the man on his roof rather than finding out why he’s on the roof in the first place); becoming the monster we came to unseat.

No, Mr. McCain, you and I stand too far away to offer much, if anything, in the way of wisdom when it comes to Iraq.  But if you insist on talking about what we should have done, let us begin not with our guns but with our presence.  Let us begin not with the last few years, but with the last century.

You may have forgotten that history, but I assure you, the Iraqis have not.  

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

Forest & Trees: How Fareed Zakaria (and So Many Others) Missed Iraq’s Most Important Lesson


Fareed Zakaria writes at CNN on the (claimed) 5 Lessons of the Iraq War.  His list?  (1) bring enough troops; (2) don’t tear down the state; (3) don’t knock down doors; (4) make a deal to include all parties; and (5) write constitutions before holding elections.

Hear me sigh.  It is a time-worn thing, this sigh of mine.

While an interesting and perhaps even accurate list, Mr. Zakaria misses the most important and obvious answer to his own question – what lessons might be learned from the war? –

Don’t do it.

Simple, really.

Don’t do it.

Just say no.

Be suspicious.

Ask questions.

Demand the truth.

If my thesis is don’t do it, don’t do what, exactly?

1. Don’t devalue the lives of your [presumed] enemies.  They love their children as much as you love yours.  Value their very existence as much as you value your own.

2. If you’re a journalist (and Mr. Zakaria is just that), do not – ever – take the word of anyone at face value, especially when they’re (a) acting out of self-interest; and (b) proposing to kill people on a massive scale.

3. Do not adopt the propagandist language of those trying to sell you on an idea that will result in the deaths of millions (and yes, it was millions).

4. Do not be sidetracked by tactics.  Focus instead on the underlying idea or proposition, asking:  (a) is it a desirable goal?  (b) will the achieving of the goal make us better people?  ( c) is the goal so important, so necessary, that it will be worth the loss of everything else?  (d) what’s the rush?  When people try to hurry you into a costly decision, chances are there’s something behind the mirror they don’t want you to see or have the time to think too much about.  (e) are there alternatives?  There are always alternatives.  Why were they not explored?  Why were they so handily dismissed?  Perhaps Chris Hedges was right in his seminal work War is a Force that Gives Us Meaning: a war is just too good an opportunity to miss out on.  It’s exhilarating.  Here’s a thought: the next war we contemplate, you might consider: (a) the fact that it’s something that can be contemplated means that it is not necessary (a real emergency that requires an armed response does not provide a lot of time to think about it – as in the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor); and (b) when it comes to truth claims from one’s own government, maybe you could have journalists who are not citizens of our country take a look at them – after all, objectivity is a benchmark of your profession – or it used to be.

Really, all of this boils down to one point, one lesson to be learned from our collective decision to invade Iraq.  It’s a simple lesson, really:

5. Do not go to war based on a lie.

The subsets of this lesson are legion: (a) do not go hastily to war – ever; (b) know the facts.  Demand them.  In the absence of verifiable facts, make no decision; ( c) Let no be our operating assumption, our first response, the objective which must be overcome by overwhelming evidence, when it comes to war; (d) always examine our own motives, for they are always suspect; (e) there are many aiders and abettors in any decision to go to war – don’t be one of them; (f) ask the real consequential questions out loud – publicly and often: is this so important that we are willing to kill children to achieve it?  Because we will; we do – whenever there is a war, we become the killers of children – our own and others; (g) make it a moral/ethical discussion, because waging war is a moral and ethical decision and abandoning ethics and morality in favor of discussing tactics is itself unethical.

As I said, these are but a few of the questions that might and, I think, should be asked in any decision about the waging of war against others.

And this, I think, is the largest gap in mainstream press coverage on our collective decision to invade Iraq, even 10 years later, when we should know better.

In 1999 (well before our invasion of Iraq), in his book Debating War and Peace: Media Coverage in the post-Viet Nam Era, Jonathan Mermin of Princeton University writes about the journalistic phenomena of taking the word of the powers-that-be inside Washington when it comes to matters of war and peace.  As the publisher’s review indicates, Mermin demonstrates that:
when it comes to military intervention, journalists over the past two decades have let the government itself set the terms and boundaries of foreign policy debate in the news. . . [showing] that if there is no debate over U.S. policy in Washington, there is no debate in the news, [further observing that] journalists often criticize the execution of U.S. policy, but fail to offer critical analysis of the policy itself if actors inside the government have not challenged it. . .Princeton University Press
Many in the press of these United States rushed to war right alongside President Bush and his administration when it came to Iraq.  Liberal and conservative, you were virtually all on board.  And you are our professional fact finders.  If I knew (and I did – from NPR’s reporting of UN sources) that the Niger yellow-cake claim was a forgery before the invasion (IAEA report on Iraq), why didn’t you?  It is your job to know.  Well, actually, you did know – since the IAEA report I heard on NPR was reported with transcript offered on CNN on March 7, 2003, 13 days before the invasion based (at least in part) on this allegation and others about Iraq’s purported (falsely) attempts to go nuclear, as the IAEA reports made clear at the time.

And ten years later, the best you have to offer us, Mr. Zakaria, is more of the same: more analysis on how we could have waged the war better and absolutely no analysis on why your own industry was so eager to facilitate the Administration’s rush to war in the first place; no reflection on how to avoid the rush to war in future; no questions or answers about the missing piece of moral and ethical reflection.

It is not enough to claim to be reporters of fact only, as you are an analyst and your piece proffers analysis.  How can you exclude from your proffered opinions so glibly any consideration about the question of whether to engage in such an exercise, restricting yourself to trying to figure out how to do it better next time?

Shame, Mr. Zakaria.

If the only lessons you learned are how to do it better as opposed to whether to do it at all, you really should be working for a defense-industry think tank.

Sadly, your five so-called lessons tell me that you’ve learned nothing at all in the last ten years.  That’s the best ‘spin’ I can put on your piece, for the alternative is truly too horrific to contemplate: that you yourself are part and parcel of the intentional misguiding of the American people on this travesty so tritely named Iraqi Freedom.

I expect more.

Nay, I demand it.

You, the press, are our only non-governmental constitutional organ of freedom.  Your job is much too important to be taken lightly.  The lessons to be learned from our invasion of Iraq are yours as much as our military’s.

No – the lessons to be learned are actually more yours than theirs.

They were being true to who they are.

Who or what were you being true to?



_______________________________
*Selecting a title for an essay on a subject I care deeply about is not as easy as one might think – especially if you want to make it tweetable.  And so, for whatever edification or amusement may result, I offer you the title rejects for this piece:  Why journalists have nothing to teach you about the lessons of war; Undoing Zakaria’s Lessons of War; Zakaria’s Box: His Lessons Aren’t Iraq’s Lessons; Zakaria’s Idol (idle?) Thinking?; What Mr. Zakaria Didn’t Learn from Iraq; Zakaria: Really?; I don’t know what school you went to. . .; War & Peace?  No: War & War; This isn’t your mama’s war sonny; Flag on the Play: Zakaria Misses the Mark – Again; Pressing the Press: Iraq, Journalism & Lost Lessons; Been There, Done That & I Don’t Want Your T-shirt; False Teaching; False Teaching/False Teachers: How Fareed Zakaria Missed the Mark on Iraq; Words of Mass Destruction: Zakaria’s “Lessons” on Iraq Still Killing After All These Years; The Killing Fields: Zakaria’s Word of Mass Destruction; Fareed Zakaria Thinking inside the box again; Still smug after all these years; History Writ Small: Why Journalists Make Bad Historians; History Writ Small:  Zakaria’s Iraq Lessons Need Schooling; History Writ Small: Five Lessons for Fareed Zakaria; History Writ Small: 5 Lessons I Wish Fareed Zakaria Knew about Iraq; 5 Paltry Lessons; Lessons from Iraq:  Zakaria Flunks the History Exam – Again; 5 Lessons Iraq Could Teach Fareed Zakaria; 5 Lessons Fareed Zakaria Didn’t Learn About Iraq; Lessons from Iraq: 5 Things Fareed Zakaria Didn’t Learn but Should Have; When It Comes to Iraq, Mr. Zakaria, There’s Only One Lesson to be Learned; Unfit to Print:  Zakaria’s Five Lessons Learned from the Iraq War.

**In the last week, 94 people (at a minimum) have been killed in violence across Iraq and 50+ injured. Al Jazeera in English and Washington Post

***Since the US invasion of Iraq, according to ORB, the UN, and others, more than 1 million civilians were killed and more than 4.5 million refugeed or internally displaced, many of whom have still not been able to return home or to anything resembling normal life.  That represents almost 20% of the population of Iraq.  Perhaps we might focus more on the place where we directly caused such whole-sale destruction before entertaining a reprise in neighboring Syria.